This page chronicles Carlisle's history with the College Football Belt, which passes to any FBS team that defeats the current holder.
Carlisle first captured the College Football Belt on 11/09/1907 after vs. Harvard (W 23–15). The program has enjoyed 1 total reign and owns a belt game record of 9-8-1.
| Start | End | Defenses |
|---|---|---|
| 11/09/1907 | 11/07/1908 | 9 |
| Game Context | Result |
|---|---|
| Challenge to Harvard Reign 11/02/1912 to 10/23/1915 | 7-29 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |
| Challenge to Pennsylvania Reign 10/07/1905 to 10/13/1906 | 0-6 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |
| Challenge to Harvard Reign 11/23/1901 to 11/22/1902 | 0-23 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |
| Challenge to Harvard Reign 11/05/1898 to 11/24/1900 | 10-22 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |
| Challenge to Harvard Reign 11/05/1898 to 11/24/1900 | 5-17 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |
| Challenge to Pennsylvania Reign 10/23/1897 to 11/05/1898 | 10-20 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |
| Challenge to Pennsylvania Reign 11/10/1894 to 10/24/1896 | 0-36 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |