This page chronicles Gettysburg's history with the College Football Belt, which passes to any FBS team that defeats the current holder.
Gettysburg has never held the College Football Belt. The team is 0-4-1 in belt games.
| Start | End | Defenses |
|---|
| Game Context | Result |
|---|---|
| Challenge to Cornell Reign 10/23/1915 to 10/28/1916 | 0-26 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |
| Challenge to Swarthmore Reign 10/13/1906 to 11/10/1906 | 4-19 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |
| Challenge to Pennsylvania Reign 10/07/1905 to 10/13/1906 | 6-6 (Tie) |
| Challenge to Pennsylvania Reign 10/23/1897 to 11/05/1898 | 0-50 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |
| Challenge to Pennsylvania Reign 11/10/1894 to 10/24/1896 | 0-32 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |