This page chronicles Thiel's history with the College Football Belt, which passes to any FBS team that defeats the current holder.
Thiel has never held the College Football Belt. The team is 0-2-0 in belt games.
| Start | End | Defenses |
|---|
| Game Context | Result |
|---|---|
| Challenge to Washington & Jefferson Reign 10/15/1927 to 10/13/1928 | 0-33 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |
| Challenge to Carnegie Mellon Reign 11/27/1926 to 10/15/1927 | 0-40 (Failed Attempt to Win Belt) |